Analyses / FICO
Fair Isaac faces VantageScore competition mandate; valuations compressed 16% intraday on FHFA ruling.
A free account reveals FICO's entry zone, price target & stop loss. Full 1-week to 1-year price forecasts are included with Pro.
The Thesis
▲ Bull Case
High-margin SaaS model (83% gross, 33% net). EPS growth 23% YoY, 27% CAGR over 5y. Strong recurring revenue from mortgage, auto, personal credit segments. If VantageScore fails to displace FICO in practice or faces adoption friction, share repricing higher likely. Trading 47% below 52w high.
▼ Bear Case
FHFA ruling removes key moat in mortgage segment (critical revenue stream). Forward P/E 31x signals limited margin-of-safety despite selloff. Debt picture unclear (no D/E ratio provided). Insider sells outnumber buys 2:1 (169 vs 76 txns). Current ratio 0.83 signals potential liquidity tightness. Market repricing may persist if VantageScore adoption accelerates.
Valuation
overvalued (pre-regulatory shock); fairly-priced post-correction (contingent on moat durability) — score 45/100
Current P/E 24.7x and forward 30.8x remain elevated vs. S&P 500 avg (~19x), even after 16% decline. P/S 10.1x, EV/EBITDA 31.3x, price-to-FCF 27.2x all signal premium pricing. However, 23% YoY EPS growth and 27% 5-yr CAGR justify some premium in a growth context. Regulatory overhang argues for caution; multiples may compress further if mortgage revenue guidance cut.
Technical Levels
Support · $870.00 (52-week low (pre-FHFA floor)) · $885.00 (Session low) · $930.00 (Current price cluster)
Resistance · $954.00 (Session high) · $1,000.00 (Psychological round; weak technical barrier) · $1,118.00 (Prior close (pre-crash))
Financial Health
Score 65/100. High profitability (33% net margin, 46% operating margin) offset by liquidity concerns (current & quick ratios below 1.0). Debt structure not provided; unable to assess balance-sheet stability. SaaS model typically carries low capex, mitigating some leverage risk, but sub-1.0 working-capital ratios suggest potential cash-flow stress or aggressive capital allocation.
Catalysts
| Q earnings call + mortgage revenue guidance | Next 4-8 weeks | high — management commentary on VantageScore displacement, cost actions, and revised annual guidance will reset market expectations. Miss or sharp guidance cut likely triggers further selloff. |
| VantageScore adoption/implementation timeline (FHFA updates) | Next 6-12 months | high — market clarity on Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac rollout speed and actual lender adoption rates will determine structural revenue impact. |
| Auto, personal credit segment growth | Ongoing | medium — if auto and personal credit (less regulated) accelerate faster than expected, could offset mortgage decline and support re-rating. |
| M&A or strategic partnerships | Uncertain | medium — management may explore acquisition targets or partnerships to diversify revenue or bolster market position vs. VantageScore. |
Risk Flags
See FICO's full trade plan — free
Create a free account to unlock the exact entry, target, and stop — plus run live analysis on any of 5,000+ tickers. No card required.
Unlock FICO free →Recent News
- FICO Stock Falls Pre-Market After Bill Pulte Declares 'No More' to FICO's Mortgage Scoring Monopoly — Orders Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac to Open Door to VantageScore (UPDATED)Yahoo
- OpenAI, Anthropic IPOs Could Spark a Selloff in These Struggling Stocks — IBM, Tesla, AppLovin Among Names at RiskBenzinga
- One Regulator Just Ended Fair Isaac's (FICO) Mortgage Monopoly. The Stock Fell 16% – Is It Justified?Yahoo
- Has Fair Isaac (FICO) Fallen Into Reasonable Territory After FHFA?Yahoo
- Fair Isaac (FICO) Stock Dropped, So What Is Behind The Latest Attention?Yahoo
You've read your 2 free analyses
Create a free account for unlimited analyses — every name on the page, plus live tools on 5,000+ tickers. No card required.
Read the full FICO analysis — free →Free to read · 2 analyses every 30 days without an account
More Analyses
FICO FAQ
Is FICO a buy right now?
Fair Isaac Corp's current read is a Recovery / Risk Revaluation setup with 55 confidence over a 6-12 months horizon. Valuation: overvalued (pre-regulatory shock); fairly-priced post-correction (contingent on moat durability). See the full bull and bear case above, or run a live analysis for the exact entry, target and stop.
Is FICO overvalued?
overvalued (pre-regulatory shock); fairly-priced post-correction (contingent on moat durability) (valuation score 45/100). Current P/E 24.7x and forward 30.8x remain elevated vs. S&P 500 avg (~19x), even after 16% decline. P/S 10.1x, EV/EBITDA 31.3x, price-to-FCF 27.2x all signal premium pricing. However, 23% YoY EPS growth and 27% 5-yr CAGR justify some premium in a growth context. Regulatory overhang argues for caution; multiples may compress further if mortgage revenue guidance cut.
What are the risks of buying FICO?
FHFA ruling removes key moat in mortgage segment (critical revenue stream). Forward P/E 31x signals limited margin-of-safety despite selloff. Debt picture unclear (no D/E ratio provided). Insider sells outnumber buys 2:1 (169 vs 76 txns). Current ratio 0.83 signals potential liquidity tightness. Market repricing may persist if VantageScore adoption accelerates.