Analyses / TSLA vs NIO
TSLA vs NIO
Side by Side
| TSLA | NIO | |
|---|---|---|
| Company | Tesla Inc | NIO Inc. |
| Price | $383.72 | $2.77 |
| Today | — | — |
| Valuation | OVERVALUED | STRETCHED ON EARNINGS |
| Valuation score | 25/100 | 30/100 |
| Setup | Range-bound with elevated valuation | Recovery attempt in a downtrend (speculative) |
| Confidence | 40 | low |
| Category | Large Cap | Large Cap |
The Case for Each
TSLA
Bull: If China production ramp news and Musk-related headlines support demand, the stock could test the 400-420 area. Revenue growth is positive at 5.19%, and the 5-year revenue growth of 24.63% shows the longer-term expansion record. Current ratio of 2.16 suggests liquidity is adequate. A close above the 389.27 day high with volume would strengthen the upside read.
Bear: Trailing P/E of 445.8x, forward P/E of 378.4x, and EV/EBITDA of 118.9x price in a lot of future growth. TTM EPS growth is -33.28%, and insider activity shows 81 sell transactions against 12 buys (418M shares sold vs 305M bought). Gross margin of 18.03% and net margin of 4% leave little cushion. Beta of 1.78 means sharp moves are likely in a market sell-off.
NIO
Bull: If revenue growth (21.09%) converts into margin improvement, the shares sit near a 52-week low ($2.71) with a market cap of about $6.7B. Sales of about 40% five-year growth show demand history. A reclaim of the $2.89 day high and prior close of $2.81 would signal short-term stabilization. Upside case rests on the Q3 2026 results (board meeting Dec 1, 2026) showing a narrower operating loss.
Bear: Operating margin is -16.07% and net margin is -17.8%, so the company is still loss-making with no P/E available. Current ratio of 0.98 leaves little liquidity cushion. Insiders sold 2.45M shares against 1.83M bought across 28 transactions. Stock is down about 45% this year per headlines and trades 1% above its 52-week low. A close below $2.71 would extend the downtrend.
Compare any two stocks, live
Run real-time analysis on TSLA, NIO, or any of 5,000+ tickers — free.
Open Sigma Terminal →