Analyses / V vs MA
V vs MA
Side by Side
| V | MA | |
|---|---|---|
| Company | Visa Inc | Mastercard Inc |
| Price | $375.28 | $574.42 |
| Today | — | — |
| Valuation | Overvalued on multiples, but quality justifies premium. | PREMIUM VALUATION JUSTIFIED BY GROWTH, BUT LIMITED MARGIN OF SAFETY |
| Valuation score | 62/100 | 62/100 |
| Setup | Growth / Quality | Growth / Quality |
| Confidence | 72 | 72 |
| Category | Large Cap | Large Cap |
The Case for Each
V
Bull: Visa operates a high-margin, recurring-revenue network with 80%+ gross margins and 50%+ net margins. Strong EPS growth (13.37% YoY, 15.85% 5Y CAGR) and revenue growth (10.92% YoY, 12.86% 5Y CAGR) reflect secular tailwinds in digital payments. Low beta (0.83) and 0.82% dividend yield offer stability. Insider buys slightly exceed sells (74 vs 78). Stock near 52-week high suggests market confidence in growth thesis.
Bear: Forward P/E of 35.0x and price-to-FCF of 32.6x are expensive relative to historical averages and broader market. P/S of 17.6x and EV/EBITDA of 29.8x signal limited margin of safety. Limited room for multiple compression if growth slows. Recent insider activity mixed (near parity). Valuation leaves little room for disappointment.
MA
Bull: Mastercard exhibits durable competitive moat, exceptional profitability (45.6% net margin, 57.6% operating margin), and consistent double-digit EPS/revenue growth (17.3% EPS YoY, 13.8% revenue YoY). Cross-border partnerships and fintech integrations (Finsei, iPayLinks, KEO Capital) signal expanding addressable market. Low beta (0.81) provides defensive equity-like exposure. Strong FCF conversion and modest 18.4% payout ratio leave room for capital return or reinvestment.
Bear: Valuation stretched across metrics: P/E 31.1x vs S&P avg ~20x, forward P/E 33.8x, P/S 15.4x, EV/EBITDA 26.5x. Price/FCF 30.8x indicates limited margin of safety on growth assumptions. P/B 66.3x reflects intangible-heavy model; tangible book value only $2.44/share. Insider selling (100 sells vs 60 buys; net -145k shares YTD) suggests limited insider conviction at current levels. Limited gross margin data obscures pricing power sustainability.
Compare any two stocks, live
Run real-time analysis on V, MA, or any of 5,000+ tickers — free.
Open Sigma Terminal →